Keywords abortion pregnancy moral status ontology pregnant woman. Where major religious groups stand on abortion pew. As society changed, the jews found that the torah needed to be updated from its original agricultural emphasis. Where major religious groups stand on abortion pew research. The traditional jewish view on abortion does not fit conveniently into any of the major camps in the current american abortion debate judaism neither bans abortion completely nor does it allow indiscriminate abortion. Judaism judaism is against abortion however provides a little leeway. Mar 17, 2015 the afterlife in judaism jewish sacred texts and literature have little to say about what happens after death. Buddhism 376 million followers tripitaka pali canon 5. As is often the case, judaisms view is quite nuanced and does not necessarily fit squarely into either side of the debate. The holy books of world religions sacred texts in world.
In the middle are those who advocate laws limiting the number of valid reasons for abortion. In practice, however, abortion is practiced in hindu culture in india, because the religious ban on abortion is sometimes overruled by the cultural preference for sons. Judaism and the forms of christianity shaped by augustines doctrine of original sin give two very different answers to this question again resulting in two divergent views on abortion. This is the mustread book on the topic of abortion. Catholics 48% say abortion should be legal in all or most cases, in spite of the catholic churchs strong opposition. It is based on the teachings of jesus christ who lived in the holy land 2,000 years ago.
Christian beliefs about abortion are divided in two phases. Although judaism clearly honors all human life, the vast majority of jews believe in a womans right to choose an abortion. The spring equinox in the earths northern hemisphere, is associated with, or also known as. This treatise uncovers the dubious alliance between on the one hand a nearly universally suspect moral position and the groups and individuals who promote it and on the other the communities and organizations of truth. What are the top ten religions and what is the holy book for. In mid2012, the public religion research institute prri published its findings from a 2012 survey of jewish values the jewish. Apr, 2020 the religious holy book of hinduism is called the vedas which is unlike that of the bible of the christians or the koran of the islam religion. To explore the views of members of many other religious groups on abortion, see our interactive website featuring data from the 2014 religious landscape study. In the modern period, moreover, jewish thinking on abortion has responded both to liberal understandings of personal autonomy as well as christian opposition to.
A 2015 pew research forum survey found that 83 percent of american jews, more than any other religious group, say abortion should be legal in allmost cases. Aug 25, 2009 in practice, however, abortion is practiced in hindu culture in india, because the religious ban on abortion is sometimes overruled by the cultural preference for sons. Surprisingly, they agree on a few very important points. Because neither of the jewish holy texts, the torah nor talmud, says anything specific about abortions, rabbis have long had to make up their own interpretations and rulings on this issue. Many of the questions seem to have no concrete answer. This factsheet summarises the attitudes and beliefs of religious groups in the uk to contraception and abortion. Of the legislation, bleich commented, judaism opposes abortion, and to the extent that this limits abortion, it needs to be supported. While judaism isnt as large as christianity and islam, its impact on the world has still been as profound.
Christianity is the worlds biggest religion, with about 2. Christians believe that jesus was the messiah promised in the old testament and they believe that jesus christ is the son of god. These stances span a broad spectrum, based on numerous teachings, deities, or religious print, and some of those views are highlighted. The augustinian doctrine argues that all human beings are born with a soul diseased and distorted by the sin of their primordial parents in the garden. What is news is when most jews agree on a particular idea or approach.
The curious consensus of jews on abortion judaism and. Therefore, the women prayed to prevent any complications. Stated simply, the jewish view of jesus of nazareth is that he was an ordinary jewish man and, most likely, a preacher living during the roman occupation of israel in the 1st century c. It has been the subject of countless articles, books, speeches and demonstrations.
Due to our fundamental belief in the sanctity of life and the jewish value of kavod habriyot, respect for human dignity, reform judaism holds that abortion is both a medical and spiritual decision that should be made by the individual within whose body the fetus is growing. Views range from the extreme conservative position that all abortions are morally objectionable to the extreme liberal position that abortion throughout all nine months of pregnancy is acceptable. Spring equinox celebrations in the northern hemisphere when day and night are of equal durations. Out of more than 600 laws of moses, none comments on abortion. Abortion is one of the most divisive and controversial issues of our day. Anti abortion, prolife views are completely compatible with liberal judaism, when truly understood. While some rabbis approve abortion for a defective fetus within the first trimester, lithuanian orthodox rabbi moshe feinstein, considered a critical halakhic voice on the issue, asserted that the operation is forbidden in cases of abnormality, as judaism does not differentiate between souls.
But, he added, it is clear in jewish law that if the mothers life or health are threatened, then the point at which an abortion takes place does not matterthe principle is that the mother comes first and we do everything to save. Schiffs intention is to trace the legal history of abortion in judaism. The psychological effects of of abortion 858 words 4 pages. For approximately three decades, the abortion debate has polarized america. Jewish law is more lenient concerning abortions in the first forty days of pregnancy as it considers the embryo to be of relatively low value during. The study sought to investigate the religious beliefs and practices of postpartum ghanaian women. For the christian and jewish perspectives, an excellent indepth guide is the book the soul of the embryo by professor david jones, a leading christian scholar. At the same time, judaism generally regards abortion as generally wrong and prohibited. Abortion draws out the clashes between two divergent world views. The implications of religious beliefs on medical and patient care. The word abortion does not appear in any translation of the bible.
A number of liberal and mainline christian and jewish faith groups and organizations have publicly stated that abortions are sometimes an acceptable option, and should remain legal. Jun 06, 2016 the religious beliefs and practices of patients play an important role in the recovery of the patient. Hinduism does not have a holy leader like the pope is among the members of the catholic religion. This article looks at some of the circumstances in which it may be permitted. Pregnant women and women in labour exhibit their faith and use religious artefacts. Apart from an overall regard for the sanctity of life, judaism finds other reasons to. Religious people walk into abortion clinics every single day in the united states, either to procure an abortion or provide one, and they. Many prolife and prochoice groups have been organized with opposing goals. The other holy book for the jewish religion is the talmud which includes the mishnah, which means repetition or study and the gemara, which means addition or completion. Abortion is still a difficult, contentious and even unresolved issue for some religious groups. The bioethical concept of life for life in judaism, catholicism, and. Many of the questions seem to have no concrete answer neither scientifically nor ethically. Religious opinions and views on abortion in examining religious opinions on abortion, one must find common ground on which to form a foundation of comparison.
Spring equinox celebrations of christianity, judaism. Thus, there is a consensus that of course abortion is appropriate to save the life of the mother unlike among certain christians. Feldman presents this as the distillation of jewish opinion on the matter, which suggests that strict laws against abortion would violate the religious freedom of jews. According to jewish religious tradition, god gave the torah to moses on mount sinai. With most of the religions to date, that common ground lies on the argument of whether or not a fetus is an actual person. As a result, various faith groups have tried to profess medical ethics. Judaism ontario consultants on religious tolerance. The antiabortion cause has been embraced by many religious christian groups, including the catholic church. Religious perspectives on abortion and a secular response article pdf available in journal of religion and health 494. The orthodox church has a definite, formal and intended attitude toward abortion.
In addition to the talmud, the torah is supported by holy books, such as the siddur, a prayerbook that includes daily prayers for morning, afternoon and evening, and special occasion prayers for events, such as holy days. The belief in allah as the one and only god, the belief in angels, the belief in holy books, the belief in the prophets, the belief in the day of judgement and the belief in predestination. The bioethical concept of life for life in judaism. The implications of religious beliefs on medical and.
Another expert who has written and lectured extensively in the field is rabbi david feldman of the jewish center of teaneck, nj. Spring equinox celebrations in christianity, judaism, neopaganism, etc. Genesis, exodus, leviticus, numbers and deuteronomy the pentateuch, but is also used to refer to the entire corpus of jewish religious teachings. Whoever destroys one life is as if he destroyed a whole world, and whoever preserves a life is as if he preserved the whole world. Religious views on the legalization of abortion abortion. Spring equinox celebrations in the northern hemisphere when day and night are of equal. Judaism does not forbid abortion, but does not permit abortion on demand.
However, judaism s position on abortion is nuanced, and both principal camps in the american debate over abortion rights can. Christianity, islam, and judaism are three of the most influential world religions in history. Alban eilir, the arrival of spring in the northern hemisphere, eostar, eostre. Apart from an overall regard for the sanctity of life, judaism finds other reasons to forbid abortion. It is not a social issue of mere preference, but an issue about life and death. The humanistic worldview says, man is the highest standard there is. It condemns all procedures purporting to abort the embryo or fetus, whether by surgical or chemical means. Religious beliefs and practices in pregnancy and labour. Antiabortion, prolife views are completely compatible with liberal judaism, when truly understood.
In judaism, views on abortion draw primarily upon the legal and ethical teachings of the hebrew bible, the talmud, the casebycase decisions of responsa, and other rabbinic literature. There is more than one religious view on abortion heres what. The romans executed himand many other nationalistic and religious jewsfor speaking out against the roman authorities and their abuses. Pdf religious perspectives on abortion and a secular response. This may seem surprising to nonjews, since christian sacred texts and islamic sacred texts both of which have their foundations in judaism focus significantly on the afterlife. In this paper, a general overview of some aspects of judaism, christianity and islams doctrines concerning informed consent, abortion, do not resuscitate dnr, euthanasia and endoflife care, and autopsies are. Rather, schiff presents a fairly unbiased examination of the sources.
The limits of religious freedom, and jewish teaching visavis rightsbased arguments for abortion. More than one religious view on abortionwhat jewish texts. Abortion from different religions perspective research paper. Religion, contraception and abortion factsheet factsheets fpa. In general, these either promote a womans right to choose an abortion, or are relatively silent on the matter. In this 30minute mysteries of the church minidocumentary made for the roman catholic diocese of brooklyn, new york, religious teachers and academics discuss the historical origins, similarities, and differences. Religious opinions and views on abortion essay 1407. While all major jewish religious movements allow or even encourage abortion in order to save the life or health of a pregnant woman, authorities differ on when and whether it is permitted in other cases. The religious holy book of hinduism is called the vedas which is unlike that of the bible of the christians or the koran of the islam religion. Rabbi daniel korobkin, spiritual leader of beth avraham yoseph of toronto congregation, an orthodox shul, said that while the jewish faith does permit abortion in cases where a mothers life is threatened, judaism views the fetus as a life and therefore one is guilty of taking a life if they commit an abortion, but it is nuanced in that it. This is said because if a woman is a member a strong religious group with equally strong views opposing abortion she may begin to feel as though she has to end the abortion due to feelings of shame and guilt associated with the abortion or because she doesnt want to. Judaism in judaism, views on abortion draw primarily upon the legal and ethical teachings of the hebrew bible, the talmud, the casebycase decisions of responsa, and other. On the grounds of religion, each religious belief has its views on the concept of abortion, in christianity abortion is considered a bad omen, an evil practice and nonacceptable by god, the roman catholic church teaches that abortion is wrong and any member of the church found involved in the practice can be excommunicated from the church.
But jews read the same texts and have different interpretations. As a result, he is not agenda driven in terms of a given position on the topic. One mosaic law about miscarriage specifically contradicts the claim that the bible is antiabortion, clearly stating that miscarriage does. It covers the literature on abortion and religion found in books, essays, journal articles, academic dissertations and web sites. Religious perspectives on abortion and a secular response. More than one religious view on abortionwhat jewish texts say june 8, 2019 the conversation patheos explore the worlds faith through different perspectives on religion and spirituality.
Generally speaking, orthodox jews oppose abortion after the 40th day, 40 41 with healthrelated exceptions, and reform jews tend to allow greater latitude. Most american jews strongly support legalized abortion. The point is that all abortion is brutalizing and partial birth abortion is more so said feldman. Nov 18, 2019 the orthodox church has a definite, formal and intended attitude toward abortion. The women in this study had a number of beliefs associated with pregnancy and delivery. Few topics cause as much debate, controversy, emotion and rhetoric as the question of abortion. The central belief was the likelihood of a negative outcome of pregnancy. Jewish views on partial birth abortion my jewish learning. The early christian views on abortion and the later christian views on abortion. Current beliefs by various religious and secular groups. I am a writer and have often thought of writing to those holding a prochoice point of view in hopes of expanding understanding. Compare christianity, islam and judaism religionfacts.
And so it is with the curious consensus of jews on abortion. Gop lawmakers often point to the bible as proof that abortion should be illegal. Religious opinions and views on abortion essay 1407 words. What are the top ten religions and what is the holy book. Abortion from different religions perspective research. The implications of religious beliefs on medical and patient care dana i. I did have a small response article on abortion published in tikkun magazine a few years ago. Pdf religious perspectives on abortion and a secular. While all major jewish religious movements allow or even encourage abortion in order to save the life or health of a pregnant woman, authorities differ on. Judaism is an abrahamic religion one of the faiths that recognize abraham as a patriarch.
The halacha puts great value on human life, and views every human life as having infinite worth. May 21, 2018 religious people walk into abortion clinics every single day in the united states, either to procure an abortion or provide one, and they often do so with the support of the faith they espouse. What do orthodox jews think about abortion and why. He will conclude his chapter on just this point but he begins by noting that the religious freedom. Oct 26, 2010 the term torah is used variably in judaism and in a strict sense refers to the five books of moses. Others include christianity islam, and the bahai faith. The majority of contemporary jews rejected this belief and judaism as a whole continues to do so. Judaism generally does not view a fetus as morally equivalent to its mother. And, unlike many of the available bibliographies, this one focuses only on the religious and moral issues, therefore providing greater depth on those two issues within one work. After the death of jesus, his followersat the time a small sect of former jews known as the nazarenesclaimed he was the messiah mashiach or, meaning anointed one prophesied in jewish texts and that he would soon return to fulfill the acts required of the messiah. Judaism and abortion according to the mishnah sanhedrin 4. We will try to present a basic overview of the jewish approach to abortion by presenting the main sources on the subject, in both the hebrew bible as well as the oral torah.
506 1 1145 775 1434 840 1483 657 494 1305 640 580 726 1164 61 893 947 721 1259 349 1402 928 741 1087 1342 446 83 772 496 1328 626 833 372 1224 1157 1052 645 698